Are the Severely Neuro-divergent and Criminally Insane Damned?
As mental illness and criminal insanity were not understood in the same way during biblical times, It is hard to make a direct comparison. the Bible does not explicitly address the fate of Severely Neuro-divergent or criminally insane individuals in terms of salvation and damnation. In addition, focusing strictly on the text can help, by examining relevant biblical principles.
Key Biblical Concepts:
-
Accountability: The Bible teaches that sin separates humanity from God (Romans 3:23, Isaiah 59:2) and that unrepentant sin leads to judgment (Romans 6:23, Revelation 21:8). As you will see it appears, however, that accountability for sin is linked to understanding and willful choice. Here are some examples:
-
Romans 2:12-16 implies that those who sin without knowledge of the law are judged differently, implying a degree of moral responsibility.
-
Luke 12:47-48 explains that punishment varies according to knowledge and intent, with those who are “unaware” receiving a lesser punishment.
-
-
Mental Capacity and Responsibility: In the Bible, Severely Neuro-divergent and Criminal insanity are not directly discussed, However we can imply that God judges based on the level of understanding of individuals:
-
In Luke 23:34, Jesus urges forgiveness on those crucifying Him, saying, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.” In other words, ignorance plays a part in culpability.
-
Deuteronomy 1:39 describes children who “have no knowledge of good or evil” as being spared judgment, which could be applied to those whose mental state prevents them from discerning morality.
-
-
God’s Justice and Mercy: God is just and merciful in the Bible (Psalm 89:14, James 2:13). God knows the heart and mind (1 Samuel 16:7, Jeremiah 17:10), suggesting He accounts for an individual’s mental capacity when judging:
-
Ezekiel 18:4-20 emphasizes individual responsibility for sin, but the context seems to imply rational decision-making.
-
1 John 4:16 and John 3:16-17 emphasize God’s love and desire for salvation, not condemnation, which means there could be leniency for those who cannot comprehend or repent because of mental disorders.
-
-
Salvation and Faith: Faith in Christ saves us in the Bible (John 3:16, Ephesians 2:8-9). It is not explicitly described in the Bible what happens to those suffering from severe mental illnesses who are unable to repent. Yet, passages like Matthew 18:3-5 (valuing childlike faith) and Psalm 86:15 (God’s compassion) suggest that God’s mercy extends to those with diminished capacities.
My thoughts:
Even though the Bible does not explicitly address the eternal fate of individuals with severe mental impairments, in my opinion the scriptural teachings on God’s justice, mercy, and consideration of individual understanding suggest that those with limited mental capacity are judged according to their ability to discern morality. God’s mercy and intimate knowledge of every circumstance may suggest that damnation is not inevitable for such individuals.
Until Next Time: Courage and God Bless you all